This is the third of a series of essays on the subject of higher knowledge and its relationship to creativity and imagination. See here for a listing of all entries in this series.
The sudden flashes of insight that I have been describing as higher knowledge can generate a wide variety of results, ranging from simple puzzle-solving to elaborate scientific theories and profound artistic inspirations. However, the one thing these diverse outcomes have in common is that they occur only after we admit that the established procedures of ordinary knowledge have failed to resolve our underlying dilemma.
The same is true of those particularly dramatic examples of higher knowledge in which the challenges that confront us are not merely intellectual but deeply personal. When that is the case, our intuitive flashes may appear as a life-changing revelation, a command from beyond our conscious awareness that upends our priorities and sets us on an unforeseen course.
Epiphanies of this sort are familiar on the individual level. Examples abound in both fiction and autobiographical writings. And yet it is rarely noted that similar transformations can sweep across entire societies at times of crisis, with collective outbursts of higher knowledge triggering artistic and scientific innovations along with novel solutions to social problems.
One such period of radical transformation occurred from 1790 to 1815, beginning when the French Revolution overthrew the old regime but continuing to reconfigure every aspect of society even after the initial phase of accelerated political reforms had fallen prey to violence and cynicism.
A similar transformation spanned the years from roughly 1895 to 1920, when the complacency of the Victorian Era was shattered by sweeping alterations in everything from transportation to women’s undergarments.
And there are signs that we are currently heading into an equivalent upheaval as we witness the stable postwar order of the last eighty years crashing into ruins all around us.
Although these generation-long waves of cultural transformation are impossible to ignore, conventional histories do their best to explain them in mechanistic terms. They avoid drawing connections among, say, revolutionary politics, innovative scientific paradigms, and romantic poetry, while reducing the participants to mindless pawns of impersonal historical forces.
However, a very different picture emerges if we interpret such episodes as communal outbreaks of higher knowledge, affecting individuals and institutions alike.
There is a recurring pattern to these outbreaks. They typically follow in the wake of a prolonged period of stagnation, during which it has been assumed that the underlying nature of reality is well understood, the most pressing social problems have all been solved, and the shape of human life is set in stone for the foreseeable future.
There may be isolated hints of dissatisfaction, often taking the form of an elite passion for exotic escapism or rumblings of discontent among the poorest and most oppressed. However, these heresies remain on the margins of society, which enables any political or economic crises to be easily papered over.
Yet the longer serious problems go unaddressed, the more vulnerable the society becomes to further shocks. The old order may continue to limp along, sustained by hopes that small, incremental adjustments will preserve the status quo or even lead to the restoration of an idealized past. But eventually something snaps.
It could be one final crisis that tips poverty over into outright destitution. Or the efforts of the ruling class to suppress dissent might become completely intolerable. But whatever the exact details, a pervasive disillusionment takes hold, and that opens the way for higher knowledge to step in.
What happens next is a mystery. Higher knowledge operates outside of normal consciousness, and those who are caught up in its workings typically remain unaware of their own motivations, both at the time and in retrospect. However, the most visible public aspect is often a widespread openness to innovative solutions that cuts across classes and alignments.
This openness may be prompted by the example of one or more charismatic leaders or may simply represent an outburst of problem-solving insights from individuals in a variety of fields. And as those insights are refined and integrated, the ultimate outcome is a reconfiguration of societal relationships in ways that could never have been foreseen.
Over the last few years, there have been recurring signs that a transformative crisis of this sort was impending in our own society — but now it seems to be fully upon us.
One indication is the spontaneous self-organization of the anti-ICE resistance in Minneapolis, an uncommon phenomenon of a kind that occurs only when a collective wave of higher knowledge touches many people simultaneously.
Another is the increasing hysteria of the existing order in response to challenges of any kind, as exemplified by the grotesque effort of the United States government to define “hostility towards those who hold traditional American views on family, religion, and morality” as domestic terrorism.
And just last month we witnessed what may have been a crucial breaking point, when the Iran war forced the entire world to hold its breath in unison at the same time as the symbolically charged vision of four astronauts on a Moon voyage was reminding us of the beauty and fragility of our home planet.
But even if we are truly on the brink of a major rupture in the fabric of history, we have no way of telling how it might unfold. Will popular uprisings spread worldwide? Will there be artistic and scientific breakthroughs that address our most pressing political and environmental problems? Will events remain peaceful and productive or descend into chaos like the French Revolution? And might the familiar semiotics of our lives be irreversibly altered, with blue jeans becoming as obsolete as knee britches or bustles?
There are no ready answers to these questions. Although the future is never predictable, periods of radical transformation present an additional degree of uncertainty. The changes they bring about are abrupt and often reflect a deliberate rejection of the past. In retrospect they are typically seen as initiating a decisive shift from one historical era to another. However, the strangest aspect of these discontinuities is the possibility that they may not be a result of conscious decision-making but be rooted in the nature of higher knowledge itself.
In my previous essay, I suggested that our sudden flashes of insight arise during moments when consciousness temporarily descends into chaos. I described such episodes as journeys “across unknown dimensions of being to places we could never have reached if we had stuck to our maps.” These transformative periods of history have the appearance of similar journeys, but enacted on the scale of entire communities rather than individual minds. And that collective property raises a series of perplexing questions.
The first of these is whether higher knowledge might be not merely a function of human brain organization but an outside force with the ability to shape history. The second is whether that would imply we as a species are being led into the future rather than charting our own destiny. And the third is what that might say about the true meaning of being human.